Quiltzilla wrote:
I certainly would never take credit for the pattern, nor would I expect someone to share knowledge gained from a class or book.
Then it sounds to me like you are probably walking on the right side of the street!
The problem is those who do want to copy someone's work, rather than simply be loosely inspired to create their own patterns. It is unfair to "steal" someone's creative product for one's own profit. I would love for our society to find
more incentives for creative output. It saddens me to think that we might not be able to find some of the wonderful books, patterns, magazines and other inspirations we enjoy, if the companies who publish, distribute and sell them to us decde they are not worth the effort. You know, kind of like HGTV deciding to kill Alex's program? Thank goodness she and Ricky and some other forward-thinkers have come up with an alternative outlet! But even they could not have invested whatever it is taking to get this going if there was no reasonable expectation of recouping the costs (and hopefully profiting a bit).
To me, though, it is a person's right to be a Cheap-O quilter, to find ways to keep costs manageable and economize as need be. We all must live within our means. I don't see an ethical dilemma in that per se. It is when it comes to taking other people's work that it is no longer Cheap-O, but outright stealing. That is a whole different matter.